While there are a lot of different types of maintenance strategies out there, most discussions about which strategy you should implement come down to comparing reactive vs preventive vs predictive maintenance.
If you are or were a part of this debate, you’re probably aware that the answer isn’t always that obvious.
Predictive maintenance is the best strategy on paper, but that doesn’t mean it is the best fit for every organization or for every asset.
Each strategy has its benefits and downsides, so we decided to create an infographic that gives you a side by side comparison of these three strategies.
We split it into 3 main sections:
- Pros and Cons
- Comparison graphs (Implementation cost and difficulty, Potential ROI, Dependency on CMMS, sensors, and training)
- How to choose the right strategy
We hope it gives you a practical introduction to this topic and serves as a good starting point for deciding which types of maintenance you want to implement in your facility.
Reactive vs Preventive vs Predictive Maintenance
One thing people often get wrong is thinking that reactive maintenance isn’t really a strategy because it doesn’t involve any proactive maintenance planning.
But that is a wrong way to think about it.
Just because you are reactive, that doesn’t mean you can’t also be strategic and organized about it.
You still want to ensure that the breakdowns are fixed as soon as possible to minimize the downtime and associated costs. This means you need to have a way to track available spare parts, quickly communicate changes in task priority, have the ability to stay on top of pending maintenance activities, and track important maintenance KPIs like failure metrics.
To be able to do all of these things, even organizations that focus on reactive maintenance are looking to implement modern CMMS software.
That being said, reactive maintenance is never a good approach to maintaining important assets. The risk is simply too big as the cost of unexpected breakdowns can be a downfall of even major corporations.
So, as a natural progression from reactive maintenance, the most obvious way to improve your maintenance operation is by implementing a preventive maintenance strategy.
Since it doesn’t have complex or expensive implementation requirements, preventive maintenance is often the go-to option for every business that wants to reduce the long-term costs of their maintenance operations and stay competitive in the market.
However, as technology improves, businesses can look to further optimize their maintenance operations with predictive maintenance by eliminating some of the disadvantages of preventive maintenance (like excessive maintenance).
But predictive maintenance isn’t without its flaws. Expensive condition-monitoring equipment that is complicated to install and specialized training you need to effectively perform it are still obstacles many organizations are not ready to tackle.
The good news is that the price of condition monitoring sensors is starting to go down, making it accessible to a wider array of organizations.
Which Types Of Maintenance Strategies Should You Use
If you carefully read the above heading, you will notice that we are going to talk about implementing multiple types of maintenance strategies, and not just focusing on a single one.
The reason for that is very simple.
Your facility has different assets that require different levels of attention. That means that it often isn’t cost-effective to implement the same maintenance strategy for all of them.
A great way to decide which assets could benefit the most from which type of maintenance is to perform an RCM analysis.
You will often find out that your critical assets deserve to be monitored through predictive maintenance, while others can be maintained through preventive and, in some cases, reactive maintenance.
As with any important business decision, research is unavoidable. The only way to make an informed decision is to:
- Understand the requirements of each strategy
- Understand the needs of your facility
- Have a clear overview of your available resources for implementation
If you’ve got that covered, the answer should present itself.
As always, if you looking for a CMMS that can help you implement any type of maintenance strategy, let’s see if Limble is the right option for you.